BR-R7170 Disc Brakes vs. BR-R785: Key Differences Every Cyclist Should Know

Posted on
in No category

When selecting the perfect disc brakes for your road bike, it’s essential to understand the distinct features of each model on the market. The Shimano BR-R7170 [paid link] hydraulic disc brakes are a popular choice among cyclists due to their impressive performance and reliability. However, when comparing them to similar models, such as the Shimano BR-R785, it’s important to analyze the specific differences to make an informed decision. This guide will walk you through the key differences between the Shimano BR-R7170 [paid link] and its competitor, the BR-R785, to help you choose the best option for your cycling needs.

1. Design and Weight Differences

The design of a brake system can influence both its performance and weight, two critical factors for cyclists.

  • Shimano BR-R7170 [paid link]: The BR-R7170 is built with a sleek and compact design, leveraging Shimano’s latest advancements in brake technology. The caliper has been engineered to reduce weight without sacrificing durability or performance. It weighs slightly less than previous models, which makes it a good choice for competitive riders aiming to reduce bike weight.
  • Shimano BR-R785: The BR-R785, while still a strong contender in terms of performance, is slightly bulkier than the BR-R7170. This can result in a marginally heavier setup, which may not be ideal for riders focused on weight savings. However, the added mass may contribute to improved modulation and heat management, which some cyclists prefer.

2. Hydraulic vs. Mechanical Actuation

Hydraulic disc brakes are known for their smooth performance and better modulation, but the type of actuation system used can vary slightly between models.

  • Shimano BR-R7170: The BR-R7170 features hydraulic actuation, which ensures smoother braking performance with less effort required at the lever. This provides excellent braking power, especially on long descents or when riding under heavy braking conditions. Additionally, hydraulic systems are less susceptible to issues like cable stretch.
  • Shimano BR-R785: The BR-R785 also uses hydraulic actuation, offering the same benefits of smooth, consistent braking performance. However, the BR-R785’s design incorporates slightly different fluid reservoirs and piston configurations, which may make it feel more responsive or progressive in certain riding conditions. Riders who prefer a more immediate braking response may favor the BR-R785.

3. Brake Pad Compatibility

The type of brake pads compatible with each model can impact the braking performance and cost of maintenance.

  • Shimano BR-R7170: This model uses Shimano’s latest brake pads, which are designed for longer wear and improved performance. The pads are also easy to replace, making routine maintenance simpler and more cost-effective. The design of the brake pad holders ensures that you get consistent pad-to-rotor contact for optimized stopping power.
  • Shimano BR-R785: The BR-R785 also uses Shimano’s high-performance brake pads, but the pads are slightly thicker compared to the BR-R7170. This gives the BR-R785 better wear resistance, but it can also make pad replacement a bit more involved. Riders looking for more aggressive braking may appreciate the extra thickness for improved durability.

4. Modulation and Power

Braking modulation is a critical aspect of overall braking performance, particularly for road cyclists.

  • Shimano BR-R7170: The BR-R7170 is designed with improved modulation capabilities. The feel at the lever is more controlled, allowing for precise adjustments in braking force. This makes it an excellent choice for riders who prioritize smooth, reliable braking during mixed-terrain rides or during long-distance road cycling.
  • Shimano BR-R785: The BR-R785 offers excellent power but is typically described as having slightly more aggressive modulation. This means it’s great for riders who need strong, immediate braking but can sometimes be a little too sharp for some riders in more nuanced braking scenarios.

5. Integration with Other Components

For riders looking to optimize their bike setup, compatibility with other drivetrain components is key.

  • Shimano BR-R7170: The BR-R7170 integrates seamlessly with Shimano’s 12-speed drivetrains, offering a smooth transition and exceptional performance. The hydraulic system also pairs well with Shimano’s Di2 electronic shifting systems, making it ideal for riders looking to build a high-performance bike with integrated electronic components.
  • Shimano BR-R785: While the BR-R785 is compatible with Shimano’s 11-speed drivetrains, it does not offer the same level [paid link] of integration with Shimano’s latest electronic systems like the BR-R7170. This means that for cyclists using Di2 or 12-speed setups, the BR-R7170 may provide better overall synergy and performance.

6. Price Point

For many cyclists, the cost of a braking system can be a determining factor.

  • Shimano BR-R7170: The BR-R7170 is positioned as a premium model in Shimano’s lineup, which means it comes with a higher price tag. However, the advanced features, lighter weight, and improved performance make it a worthwhile investment for serious riders looking for high-end performance.
  • Shimano BR-R785: The BR-R785 is generally more affordable than the BR-R7170, making it a better choice for budget-conscious cyclists who still want a reliable hydraulic braking system. While it may not offer the same advanced features as the BR-R7170, it remains a strong contender for everyday cycling.

7. Durability and Maintenance

The durability of a brake system depends largely on its design, materials, and maintenance requirements.

  • Shimano BR-R7170: The BR-R7170 is designed for longevity, with high-quality materials used in its construction. Maintenance is relatively straightforward, with easy-to-replace brake pads and minimal need for frequent adjustments. The hydraulic system ensures that the braking performance remains consistent even after prolonged use.
  • Shimano BR-R785: The BR-R785 is also durable but may require more maintenance over time due to its slightly older design. Some riders report that the brake fluid may need to be topped up more frequently, and pad replacement can be more involved compared to the BR-R7170.

8. Conclusion: Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between the Shimano BR-R7170 and the BR-R785 comes down to your specific needs as a cyclist.

  • If you’re seeking the latest in braking technology, including lighter weight, better integration with modern drivetrains, and superior modulation, the BR-R7170 is likely the better choice.
  • On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more affordable option with great performance and durability, and you don’t require the latest innovations, the BR-R785 remains a solid choice.

Ultimately, both models are excellent choices, but understanding the key differences will help you make the best decision based on your riding style and technical requirements.